Skip to content

469 dead and over a thousand missing, and Nepal says it needs no help: who is it that does not want to look?

1 min read
Share
469 dead and over a thousand missing, and Nepal says it needs no help: who is it that does not want to look?

The death toll from the flash flooding in Nepal has reached 469, the Nepalese police announced. On the same day the foreign ministry in Kathmandu said foreign assistance was not needed. "The offer of help is natural. Our security agencies are conducting search and rescue operations. For now we do not need such assistance", spokesman Lok Bahadur Chhetri said.

In the same country, at the same moment, more than a thousand people are being searched for - 650 of them foreigners, according to Nepal's interior minister Sudhan Gurung. The number of missing local residents is not known at all. The Red Cross said entire villages have been destroyed and numerous communities cut off by collapsed bridges and impassable roads, and added a sentence worth more than every government statement combined: "We still do not have a full picture of this disaster".

When a state says it needs no help

Two contradictory sentences meet here. The rescue services do not have a full picture, do not have access to part of the terrain, do not even have a count of their own missing citizens - and the ministry says at the same time that foreign teams are not needed.

One of those two sentences cannot be true. Either Nepal has the situation under control, or it does not know how many people it is looking for. Either way, refusing help is not a logistical decision but a political one.

When a state turns down what is being offered, it is usually not about capacity. It is about what a foreign team would see once it got there: how many bridges fell, how they were built, who signed them off, why the warnings did not reach the villages in time. Rescue crews pull people out, but they also photograph the rubble.

The ice that broke away

The cause of the disaster is exactly what climatologists have been forecasting for the Himalayas for years. An enormous mass of ice, mud and rock collapsed into a mountain river and set off the torrent that wiped out the towns downstream. This was not ordinary rainfall rising - this was a glacier giving way.

And the story is not over. Nepal and China warned on Thursday of further flooding, because two lakes formed on either side of their border are threatening to burst onto the same region that has already been destroyed. So while the dead from the first wave are being counted, the second one is being waited for.

The Balkans have their own unread warnings

From here it is easy to see Nepal as a distant mountain story. It is not as distant as it looks. Every summer this side of Europe gets the same lesson in a smaller format - torrents that carry away bridges built half a century ago, villages reachable by a single road, and reports that later get lost somewhere. The difference is in the number, not in the mechanism.

And the mechanism is familiar: infrastructure built for a former climate, warnings with nobody to carry them to the last village, and institutions that talk after the disaster about how well they responded.

Nepal will count its dead itself, as it announced. The question that remains is whether anyone will count how many of those 469 people could have been warned.